Maureen Marovitch believes in polyamory, the philosophy of simultaneously loving more than one person. David Finch, her live-in boyfriend, does not and he is far from silent about his wish that Maureen break up with her two other boyfriends and settle down with him. So to settle the conflict, Marovitch and Finch chose a most untraditional tack: they decide to make a film about it. They set out across North America, meeting up with eclectic people living polyamorous lifestyles: swingers, pagans, a group family and the attendees of the Loving More polyamory convention. Meanwhile, their own relationship experiments force them to confront the difficult, sometimes painful realities of their lifestyle choice. An illuminating, emotionally charged, sometimes jaw-dropping documentary about modern relationships.